Earth. Energy. Everything next.

Jordanian’s Nuclear Meltdown Resembles a Soap Opera

jordan nuclear energy nuclear suit
Jordan’s parliament voted last week to shelve the nation’s nuclear power program due to doubts over project financing.  The action stopped this divisive project viewed by some as a solution to the country’s dependence on imported energy, and by others as a reckless use of resources with unacceptable risks. The vote suspended construction of Jordan’s first reactor and also the uranium mining agreement with French energy conglomerate AREVA.  Both projects will remain inactive until new economic feasibility studies are completed.

A parliamentary report has alleged the $5 billion construction cost would likely triple when waste transport costs and decommissioning are factored in.  The report also estimated Jordan’s uranium reserves at just 12,000 tons,  less than 10 percent of the volume initially projected by pro-nuke analysis.

Environmental activists, including Dr. Ayoub Abu Dayyeh and Basel Burgan, have questioned the project’s burden on Jordan’s $4 billion USD budget deficit.  Jordan’s water poverty requires increased desalination production or an environmentally dubious tap into the Red Sea to cool nuclear reactors: it’s uncertain if costs for either option are factored into the project price tag. Security is also a concern as a Generation III reactor could potentially place the Greater Mafraq area at risk of terrorism.

Nuclear proponents have championed the strategic importance of this 20-year master program to construct up to four reactors, emphasizing a need for energy security and protection from volatile fossil fuel pricing. Advocates also propose that nuclear development would position Jordan as an electricity exporter for the wider region.

Environmentalists say the kingdom can reliably provide domestic energy needs from renewable sources such as solar and wind, with equal exportation potential.

Despite the controversy, the program had been quietly moving forward.  Last month, Jordan Atomic Energy Commission (JAEC) shortlisted Russia’s Atomstroyexport and a French-Japanese consortium consisting of AREVA and Mitsubishi Heavy Industries as project developers.

Donkeys and garbage collectors cause reaction against nuclear chief

At the same time, JAEC chief, Khalid Toukan, is being pressured to resign for alleged insults to local tribes residing in the vicinity of the proposed reactor site.  Toukan, a former deputy prime minister, is accused of calling nuclear opponents “donkeys” and “garbage collectors.”

The remarks occurred in an audio recording believed to have been made last year but of unknown origin. He maintains that the tape, which is viral in local media, was fabricated as part of a nuclear smear campaign. His theory is that a cartel of 14 foreign governments and multinational companies has conspired to derail the Jordanian program.

Bassem Tweisi, political analyst and nuclear supporter, said in an interview with Haaretz that he also believes that there is an international agenda to strip the kingdom of its right to energy independence. “We cannot continue being dependent on foreign parties to support us with energy. We cannot have our electricity plugs switched off and on from abroad,” said Tweisi. “We do not have to put up with this pressure while knowing that the hazards of a third-generation nuclear reactor are less harmful than a soap factory.”

Would his sudsy comparison fly in Chernobyl, Fukushima, and Three Mile Island?

Dr. Abu Dayyeh, environmental activist, told The Media Line in a telephone interview, “We no longer have trust in the government and the commission over this project. The nuclear program must be terminated at any cost.”

JAEC’s $5 billion forecast for the 1,000-megawatt reactor is unsubstantiated by cost data relative to water cooling, the electricity demands, nuclear waste storage and ultimate system decommissioning.

Jordan bears a hefty foreign debt load, and like many of its regional neighbors, is experiencing rising unemployment and poverty. Parliament has accused Toukan of purposely misleading the public about the project’s feasibility in stressed economic times, understating costs to deter fiscal opposition. Jordan currently imports 98% of its energy at an annual cost approaching $6 billion. Just this week, the government enacted significant price hikes for fuel and electricity, an additional burden for the strained economy to bear.

Parliamentary voting on Toukan’s dismissal was planned for a special session to be held last week, but action was deferred, allegedly under pressure from the royal court. Against the backdrop of Jordan’s anti-corruption campaign, it’s unlikely that pressure on Toukan to resign will let up.

Jordan’s government is undergoing more change: another parliamentary poll will be held before the end of the year.  The shifting economic and political sands make the winner of the nuclear debate difficult to call.  Perhaps continued environmental activism will win the day. It’s a high stakes soap opera.

Image of nuclear suit from Shutterstock

Read More

TRENDING

The pulsing planet and the earthquakes that shape our world

One of the most persistent questions in seismology concerns whether scientists will eventually be able to predict major earthquakes before they happen.

Amman’s traffic crisis is about more than cars. It’s about how we think

I believe Jordan needs a cultural transformation alongside its infrastructure investments. We must begin by redefining social prestige. Why should ownership of an expensive car be considered a greater achievement than making an environmentally responsible transportation choice? Why should travelling by bus carry a social stigma?

Why water-starved Amman keeps flooding and how underground rain tanks could help

Jordan's capital faces a troubling paradox: chronic water shortages and destructive winter floods. Hydrogeological expert Dr. Osama MN Gazal explains how underground rainwater tanks and green infrastructure could help Amman capture precious rainfall, reduce flooding and build a more water-secure future.

Can Amman become a walkable city? C40 is turning hot asphalt into green public spaces

Amman has never been an easy city to explore on foot. Now, C40 Cities and Community Jameel are reimagining Jordan's capital with cooler streets, shaded playgrounds and greener neighbourhoods. Could this sprawling city finally become more walkable?

The Flash Flood Wave Redefining Policy in the MENA Region

If you’ve ever imagined the Middle East and North...

Why Bronwyn Finnegan Chose the Nonprofit Sector Over Politics or Corporate Life

Bronwyn Finnegan could have pursued a career in politics or corporate leadership. Instead, she chose the nonprofit sector, where she focuses on financial sustainability, governance and helping mission-driven organizations build the capacity to survive and grow.

Scientists make lead-free perovskite solar cells that can weather the elements

Scientists have developed a “raincoat” for lead-free tin perovskite solar cells, helping them withstand air, moisture and heat while maintaining high efficiency.

The Essential Guide To Sustainability in Project Management

Sustainability is an approach where businesses and individuals balance the environmental, social, and economic aspects of a project such that current and future stakeholders are not overburdened with the impacts of the project in future.

Yerukim Forms a New Green Economy Where the Money is Really Green

The Yerukim members who pick up the recyclables get to keep the monetary reward, the public earns "green" bills that can be used in shops, and business owners get to be associated with environmentalism.

Choosing Riyadh over Dubai? What Investors Should Know

Saudi Arabia is deploying capital at unmatched scale to catalyze tourism and advanced industry while rewiring its power-and-water backbone. The investable frontier is widening—especially in renewables, grid storage, water efficiency/desal retrofits, and hospitality operating platforms. Prudent investors will insist on phased delivery, enforceable KPIs (energy, water, biodiversity), and RHQ/zone compliance—while pricing political-economy and reputational risks alongside growth upside.

Sell your cooking oil for biodiesel money

Want to make money on old french fry oil? Sell it.

Qatar Alternative Energy Summit Pairs Investors And Innovators

Alternative energy investors and innovators can meet n' greet in Doha, Qatar March 16 and 17.

Here’s How To Implement The Four Pillars Of Employee Engagement

If you throw a party for your work team and they are vegans, don't make it a barbecue. Know the sustainability values of your team to boost moral and retain good people.

Popular Categories