Earth. Energy. Everything next.

Why offsetting programmes can work for you… wherever you live!

carbon capture and storage, carbon dioxide, Masdar city

There are many arguments for and against carbon offsetting programmes. Some people see the wider-reaching value they offer, while others argue that the concept is flawed. And then there are others who don’t really understand how they work.

And there’s truth in the for and against sides of the argument.

There’s no point leaping to conclusions about carbon offsetting programmes—and, most importantly, whether they can work for you—without taking a look at both sides of the coin.

Are they really a good option or just a distraction? Is this a Western fad or does it have worldwide potential? Let’s take a look.

What are offsetting programmes?

Before getting started, there’s no point launching into pros and cons of a concept that might seem abstract.

So, let’s take a second to figure out exactly what offsetting programmes are.

They are typically used by larger businesses and industries who want to ‘offset’ – or balance out – the often-unavoidable carbon emissions produced in the course of doing business.

Essentially, you make up for your emissions elsewhere.

Say, for example, a company produces lots of emissions thanks to their delivery trucks. They might reduce the impact as much as possible—loading each truck up more, making the delivery routes shorter and more economical. But they still emit a lot of damaging greenhouse gases because of the heavier load.

What do they do?

Well, they invest in an offsetting programme, such as Trees for Life. Trees for Life works in the Caledonian Forest in the Scottish Highlands, replanting trees and repopulating existing woodland in order to offset carbon emissions from elsewhere.

In fact, this was just what Buzzmove, a comparison website for removals did, when they were looking to offset their greenhouse gas emissions. Now Buzzmove have their own grove in the Highlands and are pushing for the removals industry as a whole to work towards being more carbon neutral.

 What are the benefits of offsetting programmes?

Now you know exactly what an offsetting programme is, and just how it can have an impact even the most unexpected of industries (like home removals). But what are the specific benefits of investing in one?

Firstly, carbon offsetting programmes can work great as a last resort for neutralising harmful emissions. As in the above example, once you’ve tried everything else you can, like investing in more efficient technology and streamlining your services, carbon offsetting schemes can work really well to write-off those remaining emissions.

Secondly, offsetting programmes—which often work in endangered natural habitats like the Scottish Highlands or smaller communities around the world—can create wider social change, beyond that of just reducing greenhouse gases.

This is even recognised by Leo Hickman, widely considered one of the concept’s loudest detractors. He has said that there’s no point disguising ‘the fact that many of the projects that carbon offsetters support are in and of themselves ‘good’ projects worthy of our support.’

Of course, that’s not to say every project is like that, so doing your research before investing is crucial. For example, you could follow the example of Buzzmove and invest in a more local programme. This allows you to really see the impact your investment has. After all, going to visit far-flung places and track how effective their programme is will only contribute further to your carbon footprint!

Are there any downsides?

However, it’s fair to say that offsetting programmes have their downsides. Doesn’t everything, after all?

The biggest con according to detractors is that offsetting programmes simply shift responsibility, allowing companies to feel ‘off the hook’ when it comes to controlling and lessening their carbon emissions. In the Independent, Sophie Morris even likened carbon offsetting schemes to buying a Diet Coke with a supersized burger, noting that it was a smokescreen allowing consumers to reduce their own guilt, rather than actually help.

This can certainly be the case, but as mentioned in the ‘upsides to carbon offsetting’ section above, offsetting programmes should simply be a last resort to neutralise unavoidable emissions. Prior to that, working to reduce carbon emissions in the first place should be a priority.

Another negative to these schemes is that sometimes the programmes themselves aren’t all that sustainable. In “Current Carbon Offset Model Won’t Work For Saudi Arabia, 3 Reasons Why” Bushra Azhar point towards to failure of Coldplay’s forest in India, planted to offset emissions generated during their tour. However, this unfortunate outcome was likely due to environmental factors and bad planning. In short, one bad apple doesn’t spoil the bunch when it comes to carbon offsetting schemes. Trees for Life forests are flourishing, for example.

That said, research is crucial. Looking for transparency and a way to see the results when using these schemes could not be more important. That’s why Buzzmove chose a programme closer to home, rather than one further afield.

It’s also important to note that, especially when trees are involved, adding to an established woodland will always be more effective than just plonking a sapling in an empty field and hoping for the best. Common sense, it seems, is also important when looking into carbon offsetting schemes.

Finally, some people criticise carbon offsetting schemes for being a Western trend, a concept that plays into our lifestyles and responsibility-shirking sensibilities.

Is carbon offsetting just a Western trend?

Well, yes. And no. Carbon offsetting can certainly be applicable worldwide. After all, every society around the world has more similarities than they would perhaps care to admit.

Take Saudi Arabia, for example, a country which Bushra Azhar said enjoys too comfortable a lifestyle for carbon offsetting to even register as useful. After all, utilities have been described as ‘dirt cheap’ and fuel can ‘cost less than a can of soda’ there. While this is perhaps the case, a country’s situation doesn’t set the tone of each individual’s mindset.

Even in places such as the US and the UK, many people blindly refuse to accept that global warming even exists. So, despite having less incentive to use carbon offsetting schemes from a financial perspective, that doesn’t necessarily mean they wouldn’t work.

Bushra Azhar argued that thanks to Saudi Arabia’s so-called ‘lavish lifestyle’, the aforementioned shirking of responsibility would come strongly into play. Once again, the same could be said for Western societies and if offsetting schemes work in those areas, why not elsewhere?

Please comment below if you think carbon offsetting just a Western trend or can work in any part of the world.

Bhok Thompson
Bhok Thompsonhttp://www.greenprophet.com
Bhok Thompson is an “eco-tinkerer” who thrives at the intersection of sustainability, business, and cutting-edge technology. With a background in mechanical engineering and a deep fascination with renewable energy, Bhok has dedicated his career to developing innovative solutions that bridge environmental consciousness with profitability. A frequent contributor to Green Prophet, Bhok writes about futuristic green tech, urban sustainability, and the latest trends in eco-friendly startups. His passion for engineering meets his love for business as he mentors young entrepreneurs looking to create scalable, impact-driven companies. Beyond his work, Bhok is an avid collector of vintage mechanical watches, believing they represent an era of precision and craftsmanship that modern technology often overlooks. Reach out: [email protected]

Read More

TRENDING

Can AI be your new rabbi?

Researchers tested 17 AI models on Israeli rabbinical exams, raising profound questions about artificial intelligence, Jewish law, morality and human wisdom.

How to Check That Your Compounded Medication Matches Your Prescription

Learn how to verify compounded medications, check prescription labels, confirm ingredients and dosages, and avoid potentially dangerous pharmacy errors.

SpaceX caught its rocket. Amazon lost 40 satellites. The future is reusable technology

Think about what goes into manufacturing a rocket. Steel and aluminum must be produced, engines precision-machined, electronics assembled and sophisticated systems tested.

Five wind turbines collapse at the same Missouri wind farm. What’s going wrong?

Five wind turbines have collapsed at Missouri's High Prairie wind farm since 2024. What caused these failures, and what does research reveal about wind turbine safety?

Alexandra Sipa turns discarded electrical wires into couture, and shows us what fashion could become

Romanian designer Alexandra Sipa transforms discarded electrical wires into intricate couture lace, combining sustainable fashion, Romanian heritage and traditional craftsmanship.

Why Bronwyn Finnegan Chose the Nonprofit Sector Over Politics or Corporate Life

Bronwyn Finnegan could have pursued a career in politics or corporate leadership. Instead, she chose the nonprofit sector, where she focuses on financial sustainability, governance and helping mission-driven organizations build the capacity to survive and grow.

Scientists make lead-free perovskite solar cells that can weather the elements

Scientists have developed a “raincoat” for lead-free tin perovskite solar cells, helping them withstand air, moisture and heat while maintaining high efficiency.

The Essential Guide To Sustainability in Project Management

Sustainability is an approach where businesses and individuals balance the environmental, social, and economic aspects of a project such that current and future stakeholders are not overburdened with the impacts of the project in future.

Yerukim Forms a New Green Economy Where the Money is Really Green

The Yerukim members who pick up the recyclables get to keep the monetary reward, the public earns "green" bills that can be used in shops, and business owners get to be associated with environmentalism.

Choosing Riyadh over Dubai? What Investors Should Know

Saudi Arabia is deploying capital at unmatched scale to catalyze tourism and advanced industry while rewiring its power-and-water backbone. The investable frontier is widening—especially in renewables, grid storage, water efficiency/desal retrofits, and hospitality operating platforms. Prudent investors will insist on phased delivery, enforceable KPIs (energy, water, biodiversity), and RHQ/zone compliance—while pricing political-economy and reputational risks alongside growth upside.

Sell your cooking oil for biodiesel money

Want to make money on old french fry oil? Sell it.

Qatar Alternative Energy Summit Pairs Investors And Innovators

Alternative energy investors and innovators can meet n' greet in Doha, Qatar March 16 and 17.

Here’s How To Implement The Four Pillars Of Employee Engagement

If you throw a party for your work team and they are vegans, don't make it a barbecue. Know the sustainability values of your team to boost moral and retain good people.

Popular Categories