Forests may not be the greatest carbon sinks – here’s why

Saudi Arabian mangrove forests
It can take decades of forest growth before the ‘cooling’ CO2 sequestration can overtake these opposing ‘warming’ processes, finds new study on Yatir Forest (above).

We’ve been buying carbon credits, and have been busy planting trees hoping to stave off climate change, but the simple formula we’ve learned in recent years – forests remove the greenhouse gas carbon dioxide (CO2) from the atmosphere; therefore forests prevent global warming – may not be quite as simple as we thought, finds a new research project.

It could take decades until trees we plant now will have any effect on the overall greenhouse gases they sequester.

Forests can directly absorb and retain heat, and, in at least one type of forest, these effects may be strong enough to cancel out a good part of the benefit in lowered CO2. This is a conclusion published January 22 in Science by scientists from the Weizmann Institute’s Faculty of Chemistry in Israel.

For the past 10 years, the Weizmann Institute has been operating a research station in the semi-arid Yatir Forest, a pine forest at the edge of the Negev Desert. This station is part of a world-wide project composed of over 400 stations, called FLUXNET, which investigates the relationship between forests, the atmosphere, and climate around the globe.

yakir forest global warming israelA tool in place at the Yatir Forest. A living lab to study the effects of global warming on forests.

The contribution of the Yatir station, says Prof. Dan Yakir is unique. It “is one of very few in the semi-arid zone, which covers over 17% of the Earth’s land surface, and it has the longest record of the processes taking place in semi-arid forests.”

Forests counteract the greenhouse effect by removing heat-trapping CO2 from the atmosphere and storing it in living trees. Over the years of measurement, Prof. Yakir’s group has found that the semi-arid forest, even though it’s not as luxuriant as the temperate forests farther north, is a surprisingly good carbon sink – better than most European pine forests and about on par with the global average.

This was unexpected news for a forest sitting at the edge of a desert, and it indicated that there is real hope for the more temperate forests if things heat up under future global climate change scenarios.

But forests do more than just store CO2, and Prof. Yakir, together with Dr. Eyal Rotenberg, decided to look at the larger picture – the total energy budget of a semi-arid forest. The first hint they had that other processes might be counteracting the cooling effect of CO2 uptake came when they compared the forest’s albedo – how much sunlight is reflected from its surface back into space – with that of the nearby open shrub land.

They found that the dark-colored forest canopy had a much lower albedo, absorbing quite a bit more of the sun’s energy than the pale, reflective surface of the surrounding areas. In a cloudless environment with high levels of solar radiation, albedo becomes an important factor in surface heating.

Next, the researchers looked at the mechanisms for “air conditioning” within the forest itself. To cool down, trees in wetter areas of the globe use water-cooled systems: They open pores in their leaves and simply let some of the water evaporate, drawing heat away in the process. But the semi-arid pine forest, with its limited water supply, is not built for evaporation. The scientists found that it uses an alternative, efficient, air-cooling system instead.

As semi-arid forests are not as dense as their temperate counterparts, the air in the open spaces between the trees comes into contact with a large surface area, and heat can be easily transferred from the leaves to the air currents. This semi-arid air cooling system is quite efficient at cooling the treetops, and this cooling, in turn, leads to a reduction in infrared (thermal) radiation out into space.

In other words, while the semi-arid forest can cool itself well enough to survive and take up carbon, it both absorbs more solar radiation energy (through the albedo effect) and retains more of this energy (by suppressing the emission of infrared radiation). Together, these effects turned out to be stronger than the scientists had expected. “Although the numbers vary with location and conditions,” says Prof. Yakir, “we now know it will take decades of forest growth before the ‘cooling’ CO2 sequestration can overtake these opposing ‘warming’ processes.”

Prof. Yakir (left) and Dr. Rotenberg then asked one more question: If planting semi-arid forests can in fact lead to warming over a good part of the forests’ life cycles, what happens when the opposite process – desertification – takes place? By applying what they had learned to existing data on areas that have turned to desert, they found that desertification, instead of hastening global warming, as is commonly thought, has actually mitigated it, at least in the short term.

By reflecting sunlight and releasing infrared radiation, desertification of semi-arid lands over the past 35 years has slowed down global warming by as much as 20%, compared with the expected effect of the CO2 rise over the same period. And in a world in which desertification is continuing at a rate of about six million hectares a year, that news might have a significant effect on how we estimate the rates and magnitude of climate change.

Says Prof. Yakir, “Overall, forests remain hugely important climate stabilizers, not to mention the other ecological services they provide, but there are tradeoffs, such as those between carbon sequestration and surface radiation budgets, and we need to take these into consideration when predicting the future.”

Facebook Comments



Get featured on Green Prophet. Email us with tips and news: [email protected]

65 thoughts on “Forests may not be the greatest carbon sinks – here’s why”

  1. Dewitt says:

    Cleopatra two takes on the internet casino på nätet sveriges bästa nätcasino (Dewitt) players to Ancient Egypt
    with its thrilling graphics and wonderful sound effects.

  2. Hector says:

    Advertisement tarnish removing products can additionally be made use of to eliminate colour discolorations
    from clothes.

  3. When you have acknowledged the certain set of conditions of an chosen Casino, you happen to be want inside the guarantees
    with the web casino online svenska – -.

  4. Victorina says:

    Pointer Three: When the detergent as well as bleach are
    totally dissolved in the water, add your garments.

  5. It is only by way of the online casino gratis bonus testimonials that you will be able to get
    such details.

  6. Kennith says:

    There are actually 4 typical types of waffle creators offered to individuals:
    range leading, cycle, straight Belgian as well as rounded Belgian.

  7. Natalia says:

    We also list a couple of online bonuses and jackpots for these who are registering for the 1st time at the selected
    United Kingdom casino.

    Here is my web page: bonusar (Natalia)

  8. This license to operate an on-line casino
    is set in compliance with the strict regulations administered by
    the Gaming Authority.

    my homepage :: online casino software providers (

  9. Erlinda says:

    Amazon reviewers additionally like the Cook’s Selection;
    users offered that 4.4 away from superstars around 135 testimonials.

  10. An engaging style is important if an online casino slot is to turn into an on the web casino classic.

    Look at my blog post; nätcasinon sverige

  11. Dacia says:

    We test the cash-out procedures of dozens of on the internet UK casinos to make certain that
    only the fastest get top spots in our ratings.

    My web blog :: bästa svenska casino – Dacia,

  12. Due to the fact that you left them in a damp pile for a few days or even more,
    if you have mold and mildew increasing on your clothing
    it’s most likely.

  13. Wonderful goods from you, man. I’ve understand your stuff previous to and you’re just extremely fantastic.
    I really like what you’ve acquired here, really like what
    you are saying and the way in which you say it.
    You make it entertaining and you still care for to keep it smart.
    I can not wait to read much more from you. This is actually a terrific web site.

    my blog post; Korean restaurant near here

  14. Elizbeth says:

    Washing your waffle mold adequately after each usage is
    crucial for several main reasons.

  15. In 1922 a long boat dock was constructed
    at Dittisham to enable steamers to call whatsoever states of the tide.

  16. In the USA, where the gambling laws are really stringent, the on the web casinos
    largely operate from the Caribbeans.

    My blog post – casino med free spins

  17. Elizbeth says: evaluators also like the Gourmet chef’s
    Choice; individuals gave it 4.4 from superstars across 135 assessments.

  18. It won’t have an effect on you directly if the
    Bill passes into law, but it will provide even much more safety for your gambling.

    Here is my homepage; free spins game

  19. Mario says:

    You can make 300 requests per day.

  20. Prior to the 1st usage, a lot of waffle manufacturers encourage oiling the grids with a newspaper towel
    or spray bottle (like PAM).

  21. Elsie says:

    This machine will get the entire feline and also dog hair
    along with different other irritants on your flooring.

  22. This online casino was developed by a team of sector experts with much more than 30 years expertise
    in gaming and the results speak for themselves.

    my webpage; internet casino (

  23. Velva says:

    Take pleasure in all the fantastic benefits of having this
    convenient cleaner in the convenience of our own house.

  24. The HEPA feature is an extremely important quality and also several modern vacuum cleaners
    now have this.

  25. Only specialist casino web sites provide players with a short introduction to its
    game kinds & payment strategies.

    Look at my web page; free spins codes

  26. Blackjack is perhaps one of the oldest on the web casino online svenska games that draws an person in. Blackjack can be a single player game.

  27. In reality Net poker has been accountable for the amazing development of Holdem on the Net.

    my page – online casino for sale costa rica []

  28. And that’s not to mention the Loyalty Points you earn with
    every single wager at Initial Internet and can redeem for actual income.

    my web-site; sverige casino

  29. Therefore it has been said by the authorities to have a fixed amount for
    playing casino games so that a particular person might not shed a large amount.

    Feel free to surf to my website internet gambling

  30. Also, the fact remains that individuals in today’s modern era
    are focused on creating swift cash.

    Here is my web site – bästa nätcasinot

  31. Alonzo says:

    This is due to the fact that the automated cleanser weighes
    role as well as is suggested to tidy huge swimming pools.

  32. It is the identical goes with the internet slots this equipment is developed to make certain that
    the minimum quantity does not fall beneath a certain limit.

    Take a look at my weblog: nätcasinon sverige

  33. Clothing Advisor is a reseller of brand name as well as
    developer products, and is not an authorized dealer of the discussed business.

  34. If we do not know about them we can not take benefit of the easy money.

    Also visit my web site – nätcasinon sverige

  35. In fact, the first on the web sports book was launched by Intertops Casino and Sports Book prior to Internet Casinos

    my site :: las vegas usa online casino reviews

  36. Possibilities are high (and there have been numerous circumstances),
    that you will be cheated by the algorithm that an on-line
    mister green casino is utilizing.

  37. My.Fool.Com says:

    That has a cycle of 2.5 several hours that harmonizes cleaning up the pools flooring as well as the wall structures.

  38. Raleigh says:

    The quality network launches waffles effortlessly every single time (no requirement for additional
    lubrication) and is an air to clean.

  39. In order to look for the most notable most net casino azines you have to browse the on line sveriges casino testimonials.

  40. Whilst getting an online casino lover, you are often in search of new on-line casinos and Web Casino Critiques will take you there.

    my page bästa nätcasinot (

  41. Gina says:

    We athletes could invest a good deal of tough earned money on our equipment,
    so it is necessary to cleanse them with treatment so these products last you a long time.

  42. Veda says:

    So, you innovators out there, there is a need for a vacuum much like this Bissell for us seniors.

  43. If we do not know about them we can not take benefit of the easy income.

    Here is my website :: casinospel gratis (

  44. On-line casinos, on the internet poker, on the internet sports betting,
    among other people, are some of the frequent types of Internet gambling.

    Also visit my site free spins bonus

  45. Lovie says:

    Washing garments in many international nations is
    as simple as walking down the block to drop-off your stinky tee shirts & shorts at someone
    else’s residence.

  46. We are the original web svensk casino guide (
    internet site and had been founded in 1995, back when the online gambling sector
    was nevertheless very young.

  47. Ladonna says:

    Any of these waffle producers are going to be impressive additions to your kitchen area and deliver you with mouth watering waffles
    any time you wish.

  48. Terrell says:

    Individuals with bad credit in California search for
    vehicles everyday that can suit their needs.

    Also visit my web page; bad credit auto loans Atlanta – Terrell,

  49. discount birkenstocks

  50. In some instances, late fine is applicable also in situation of
    delayed payments Coretta Hendley it’s the correct of an person to get
    an experienced medical service particularly if it’s a severe disease.

  51. you never see on TVBehind every glittering NFL game on television is a world of happy players who reside inCalifornia. The allegations herein, except as to the Plaintiffs, are based on information argue that “this” is football (insert Tim Allen grunt here) and nothing is going to change game, so we know with him you’ve got size and speed, toughness, quickness, and you better

  52. memory..A browse over directories or even a quick search on auction sites Cheap Pittsburgh Steelers Jerseys if youremove all the chunks ofasphalt and maybe one ortwo inches of the soil immeRemember you’re year,” said Casserly, whose own proposal and one from the league office were combined in the

  53. google says:

    Hi there would you mind letting me know which hosting company you’re using?
    I’ve loaded your blog in 3 completely different web browsers and I
    must say this blog loads a lot quicker then most.

    Can you suggest a good web hosting provider at a honest price?
    Cheers, I appreciate it!

    Here is my blog post – google

  54. So, these guys with their expertise in taking apart complex situations to be able to render linear analysis of fairly simplified relationships are suggesting exactly what? (And you know there is a pack of hyenas just ready to pounce on any bit of seeming contradiction as “evidence” that we don’t need to do anything at all). So, sure, let’s cut down all the pine forests sheltering arid soils, ramp up the old albedo and say it’s good for the planet. Hmmmmmmmmmm. Not convinced.

  55. Pingback: Geri Salsig
  56. Pingback: Geri Salsig
  57. Pingback: Allen Yorke
  58. Pingback: Beyond Business
  59. Pingback: Carbon
  60. Pingback: Z-Tech Sales, Inc.
  61. Pingback: Karin Kloosterman
  62. Pingback: greenprophet

Comments are closed.