Canada Muzzles Climate Science Cheney/Bush-Style

canada climate scienceBush era US climate science policy seems to have moved north to Canada, argues Susan.

A student researcher at the University of Toronto has exposed a draconian shut-down of climate science in Canada. This is a first for Canada – an advanced democracy, but a democracy that has the resource-curse of vast oil sands potential. James Birch does research in a thirty person lab focused on climate change research and adaptations headed by Dr. Brad Bass, the co-recipient of the IPCC Nobel Prize for climate science.

Birch and his fellow student researchers have decided to go public, to get word out to voters, because climate scientists including Dr. Bass have had their jobs shut down and have been silenced.  Writing to Clean Break Birch says that the professional climate scientists heading up the climate science labs have been forbidden to speak out.

“Our scientists have been muzzled, and their ability to go to press has become tightly managed by a new “media relations office” put forth by the Harper Government” says Birch.

Dr. Bass is among many other Environment Canada scientists who have had their jobs cut by the Harper government, yet, because of the complete muzzling of Environment Canada scientists, the Canadian voter is as unaware of this fact as US voters were of the extreme silencing of US scientists under Cheney and Bush. In fact, what is happening in Canada is even worse. Even Bush did not fire our leading climate scientists. We cannot just shoot the messenger.

“Over the past several months we have seen major cuts to Environment Canada that are leaving it without any real scientific or research power. We have seen many prominent scientific jobs cut, research funding slashed, and our ability to effectively do environmental assessment and management largely neutralized”.

“The tools and researchers necessary in order to adequately measure the consequences of the Athabasca Tar Sands are presently in a questionable state of limbo,” Birch says. He is brave to come forward with this information, as it must shortchange any possible future he himself might expect in climate science, after some years invested in the university level education to get to the position he is in in a lab headed by a Nobel-prize winning IPCC scientist.

This draconian move on the part of the conservative Harper government is so extreme that it has even received censure from one of its own party members.

“Environment Canada is now “open for business” – you may now hire their award-winning scientists at will, privatize their research and keep them from working in the public interest,” says conservative MP, Tony Clement.

Under the tar-sands-friendly conservative policy of the Harper government, new budget cuts “will effectively leave Environment Canada powerless and effectively useless.”

For Israel, which recently discovered oil, the lesson is clear. Even a real democracy like Canada can be corrupted by the Resource Curse. American politics have already been corrupted, and the effects are felt worldwide, as we have covered here, for example: American Elections Are Bad For The Nile Delta

Read more on Climate Change:


Leviathan Gas Discovery Could be The Mother of All Resource Curses
Climate Change Denial and the Climate of Fear
Dear Global Clean Energy Sector, Please Truth-Bomb the US Voter

6 COMMENTS
  1. The Harper government came to power with a majority government, but not with the support of the majority of Canadians. About 2/3 of the population are opposed to his right-wing and unscientific approach to… well, just about everything. It’s not all his fault, though. Vote splitting and the tendency for left-leaning citizens not to vote have helped him and his cronies come to power. I wonder what will be left of the Canada I love by the next election, just shy of four years from now.

  2. Big deal! Climate ‘scientists’ getting fat on the taxpayer dollar.
    ‘[A] thirty person lab focused on climate change research’ indeed!
    Get a proper job.
    Like it or not, Harper was democratically elected, with a majority (difficult in Canada).

  3. Big surprise! We might as well rename democracy the “Hive” seeing as we are all just drones and workers feeding the monarchy at the top. If people would stop and think about what is really going on they would realise that we are blindly leading ourselves back to the stone ages just so that a select few on our planet can profit. Most people now can’t even afford to protest the changes, missing a day of work to stand up for a cause leads to them not eating that week, so I guess in the end the government is working as intended… keeping us all passive tax machines to fuel their propaganda and endless pockets. I feel sad for the new countries that are “embracing” democracy or capitalism in real terms, because they think they are getting freedom, but what they are really getting is more imbeciles to make up their minds for them on a daily basis without any say in where the money ends up. Record debts etc, yet I don’t see a single politician willing to work for 50% of their wages, which would put them on par with the rest of the public earnings….

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

TRENDING

Huge Fish Nursery Discovered Under Freezing Arctic Seas

In 2019, an underwater robot camera exploring the seabed...

Remilk makes cloned milk so cows don’t need to suffer and it’s hormone-free

This week, Israel’s precision-fermentation milk from Remilk is finally appearing on supermarket shelves. Staff members have been posting photos in Hebrew, smiling, tasting, and clearly enjoying the moment — not because it’s science fiction, but because it tastes like the real thing.

The US leaves 66 United Nations organizations to “put America first”

The world needs a reset and to restart well intentioned cooperation projects from start. Because right now the UN and EU projects look like software built on code from the 80s, rickety, patched, slow to adapt, and prone to crashing under the weight of outdated assumptions.

Turkey named as climate change COP31 home in 2026

Murat Kurum as President-Designate of COP31

Ancient air trapped in Canadian salt bubbles foretells climate future

Opening these samples is like cracking open air that existed long before dinosaurs, before forests, before animals of any kind. As lead researcher Justin Park put it: “It’s an incredible feeling to crack open a sample of air that’s a billion years older than the dinosaurs.”

Qatar’s climate hypocrisy rides the London Underground

Qatar remains a master of doublethink—burning gas by the megaton while selling “sustainability” to a world desperate for clean air. Wake up from your slumber people.

How Quality of Hire Shapes Modern Recruitment

A 2024 survey by Deloitte found that 76% of talent leaders now consider long-term retention and workforce contribution among their most important hiring success metrics—far surpassing time-to-fill or cost-per-hire. As the expectations for new hires deepen, companies must also confront the inherent challenges in redefining and accurately measuring hiring quality.

8 Team-Building Exercises to Start the Week Off 

Team building to change the world! The best renewable energy companies are ones that function.

Thank you, LinkedIn — and what your Jobs on the Rise report means for sustainable careers

While “green jobs” aren’t always labeled as such, many of the fastest-growing roles are directly enabling the energy transition, climate resilience, and lower-carbon systems: Number one on their list is Artificial Intelligence engineers. But what does that mean? Vibe coding Claude? 

Somali pirates steal oil tankers

The pirates often stage their heists out of Somalia, a lawless country, with a weak central government that is grappling with a violent Islamist insurgency. Using speedboats that swarm the targets, the machine-gun-toting pirates take control of merchant ships and then hold the vessels, crew and cargo for ransom.

Leopoldo Alejandro Betancourt López Turned Ocean Plastic Into Profitable Sunglasses

Few fashion accessories carry the environmental burden of sunglasses. Most frames are constructed from petroleum-based plastics and acrylic polymers that linger in landfills for centuries, shedding microplastics into soil and waterways long after they've been discarded. Leopoldo Alejandro Betancourt López, president of the Spanish eyewear brand Hawkers, saw this problem differently than most industry executives.

Why Dr. Tony Jacob Sees Texas Business Egos as Warning Signs

Everything's bigger in Texas. Except business egos.  Dr. Tony Jacob figured...

Israel and America Sign Renewable Energy Cooperation Deal

Other announcements made at the conference include the Timna Renewable Energy Park, which will be a center for R&D, and the AORA Solar Thermal Module at Kibbutz Samar, the world's first commercial hybrid solar gas-turbine power plant that is already nearing completion. Solel Solar Systems announced it was beginning construction of a 50 MW solar field in Lebrija, Spain, and Brightsource Energy made a pre-conference announcement that it had inked the world's largest solar deal to date with Southern California Edison (SCE).

Related Articles

Popular Categories