Breastfeeding Moms More Agressive than Those Who Use Bottles

muslim woman breastfeeding group

Breast feeding moms have lower blood pressure and behave more aggressively compared to women who are bottle-feeding their children, suggesting that breast-feeding dampens the body’s typical stress response to fear, new research suggests.

Women who breast-feed are far more likely to demonstrate a “mama bear” effect — aggressively protecting their infants and themselves — than women who bottle-feed their babies or non-mothers, suggests a new study in the September issue of Psychological Science.  The small-scale study conducted in the US investigated something known as ‘lactation aggression’ or ‘maternal defense’ in mammals. Previously, we’ve documented benefits of breastfeeding, religious attitudes towards the practice,  as well as tips to breastfeed in public in the Middle East.

Breastfeeding Benefits to Baby Better Documented Than to Mom

“Breast-feeding has many benefits for a baby’s health and immunity, but it seems to also have a little-known benefit for the mother,” said Jennifer Hahn-Holbrook, a postdoctoral fellow in the UCLA Department of Psychology and the study’s lead author. “It may be providing mothers with a buffer against the many stressors new moms face while at the same time, giving mothers an extra burst of courage if they need to defend themselves or their child.”

The aggression demonstrated by breast-feeding mothers has its limits, Hahn-Holbrook added.

“Breast-feeding mothers aren’t going to go out and get into bar fights, but if someone is threatening them or their infant, our research suggests they may be more likely to defend themselves in an aggressive manner,” she said.

Hahn-Holbrook was aware that non-human female mammals, including macaques, rats, mice, hamsters, lions, deer, sheep and others, display more aggression when they are lactating than at any other reproductive stage, but she couldn’t find any research that tested that reaction in people. So she decided to set up the first experiment to study lactation aggression in humans.

Study Design

For the study, researchers recruited three groups of women — 18 nursing mothers, 17 women who were feeding formula to their babies and 20 non-mothers. Each woman was asked to compete in a series of computerized time-reaction tasks against a research assistant posing as an overtly rude study participant. The women’s infants were supervised in an adjoining room. Upon winning a round in the competition, the victor was allowed to press a button and deliver a loud and lengthy “sound blast” to the loser — an act of aggressiveness.

The researchers found that breast-feeding mothers delivered sound blasts to the rude research assistant that were more than twice as loud and long as those administered by non-mothers and nearly twice as loud and long as those by bottle-feeding mothers. This was true both before and after the breast-feeding mothers nursed their infants.

Stress Levels and Breastfeeding

They also measured participants’ stress levels via blood pressure during the experiment. Breast-feeding mothers’ systolic blood pressure was found to be approximately 10 points lower than women who were feeding formula to their infants and 12 points lower than non-mothers.

Previous research in non-human mammals has shown that lactation enables heightened defensive aggression by down-regulating the body’s response to fear, a phenomenon that benefits the survival of both mothers and their offspring. The lower blood pressure seen in the breast-feeding mothers during acts of aggression, the researchers say, is an indication that the same mechanism is likely at work in humans as well.

Breastfeeding Rates in the USA and MENA

According to the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) website, breastfeeding rates in the United States have been steadily increasing from 2000 – 2007, with recent data showing that at birth, 75% of babies born in 2007 were breastfeed. That number dropped to 43.8% by 6 months.  Across the Middle East and North Africa, breastfeeding rates vary considerably from country to country.  In Qatar, only 12% of mother’s breastfeed their 4 month olds; in Iran that number goes up to 49%; in Jordon, it’s 28% and in the UAE, 34%.

Overall, 38% of babies in MENA younger than four months were exclusively breastfeed, according to one data gathering site. At six months, 26% were still getting all their nutrition exclusively from mothers’ milk. These lower numbers have led to some calling breastfeeding a dying art in the Middle East.

Read More Breastfeeding News:
Ten Tips for Breastfeeding Your Baby in Public in the Middle East
Breastfeeding and Judaism
Natural Herbs for Breast Health and Enhancement

Tinamarie is a regular contributor to Follow her @ModernLoveMuse. She blogs at

Facebook Comments



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

fourteen + seven =