Organic food. It may cost more at the shopping till, but it delivers priceless benefits for biodiversity, animal welfare and rural economies, as well as reducing reliance on fossil fuels. Many people also believe, and there is some evidence to back this up, that food fertilised with compost instead of chemicals will be nutritionally superior.
It’s a debate that has been raging for decades, but the lack of scientific research has made claims by either side difficult to back up.
Until now, that is.
A review of scientific papers published last week by the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine which concluded: “…there are no important differences in the nutrition content, or any additional health benefits, of organic food when compared with conventionally produced food.”
But that’s not the end of the story. The study, commissioned by the UK’s Food Standards Agency (an independent government department) came under fire from the organic movement for excluding 109 of the 164 published studies from their analysis. The review also ignored findings from a recent European Union-funded study involving 31 research and university institutes and the publication, so far, of more than 100 scientific papers, at a cost of 18million Euros.
The Soil Association’s policy director, Peter Melchett (you can find a street in Tel Aviv named after his great-grandfather), said:
“We are disappointed in the conclusions the researchers have reached. The review rejected almost all of the existing studies of comparisons between organic and non-organic nutritional differences. Although the researchers say that the differences between organic and non-organic food are not ‘important’, due to the relatively few studies, they report in their analysis that there are higher levels of beneficial nutrients in organic compared to non-organic foods.”
Some say that the FSA-backed came as no surprise, given the Agency’s pro-GM stance and history of hostility towards organic food. While the nutrition debate is set to rage on, organic agriculture remains the greenest way of feeding the planet – and not least the Middle East!
Photo credit: D Sharon Pruitt.
[…] A furor of debate is breaking over a statistical analysis of data on food. Over 200 studies on organic and conventionally raised produce, grains, eggs, milk, poultry and meat were collated by Stanford University’s Center for Health Policy and broken down for comparison. The research was published in the Annals of Internal Medicine this month and concludes that organic produce has little nutritional value over the conventionally raised. This isn’t the first such study Green Prophet has reported. […]
[…] A furor of debate is breaking over a statistical analysis of data on food. Over 200 studies on organic and conventionally raised produce, grains, eggs, milk, poultry and meat were collated by Stamford University’s Center for Health Policy and broken down for comparison. The research was published in the Annals of Internal Medicine this month and concludes that organic produce has little nutritional value over the conventionally raised. This isn’t the first such study Green Prophet has reported. […]
[…] all do right? That’s why we go to the gym, fight for the right for clean air and water, and eat healthy organic food. As environmentalists with eyes wide open, some of us take vitamin supplements, like Omega 3, and […]
[…] Cross-posted from The Green Prophet […]
the debate will roll on forever, but the thing to consider is that we’re not just trying to get healthier food, but cut down on pesticide use that not only hurts the food, but our environment.
Interesting how no newspapers I read reporting this issue mentioned all the studies left out.
This seems to me one of those cases the pro-conventional guys will long cite as proof against the organics, and the organics will long deny…like a Talmudic debate in which there is no correct answer.
The Organic Food Debate Rages On http://tinyurl.com/ku4986 + http://tinyurl.com/lpdwd5 <– Both great articles 🙂
The Organic Food Debate Rages On http://bit.ly/q3d6X
The Organic Food Debate Rages On: Green Prophet Organic food. It may costs more at the shopping till, but it del.. http://bit.ly/OPmv1
The Organic Food Debate Rages On: Green Prophet Organic food. It may costs more at the shopping till, but it del.. http://bit.ly/12XWrN