Sinai’s Ecological Future Hangs in the Balance

Red Sea, Mediterranean Sea, Sinai Peninsula, ecology, development, sustainable development, EgyptAs part of the 1979 peace treaty with Israel, the Sinai Peninsula was restored to Egyptian control – an event that the country celebrated with some fanfare on April 25th, 2012. On that same day, the Egyptian Prime Minister Kamal Ganzouri witnessed two separate development plans that were signed between the Social Development Fund (SFD) and governors of both the Northern and Southern Sinai governorates.

The main goal of these agreements is to extend water networks and create jobs – a welcome move for a largely neglected area of the country. But Sinai development has also become a hot pitching point for presidential candidates, and environmentalists are worried.

Under Hosni Mubarak’s regime, Sinai was the country’s forgotten corridor and limited development occurred. While this has deprived the local Bedouin population access to decent infrastructure, it has also fostered a healthy stream of tourists attracted by the Red Sea’s marine bounty and the slow pace of life.

Since Mubarak was ousted, a certain amount of informal development has taken place. Tireless conservation groups such as Hurghada Environmental Protection and Conservation Agency (HEPCA) have taken strides to monitor opportunists and protect the environment, but they are easily overpowered.

SFD’s Chief Ghada Wali signed an agreement with North Sinia’s Governor Major General E-Sayed Abdul-Wahab to contribute 1.5 million Egyptian pounds towards developing 21 km of water networks that will be distributed to 6 different parts of the governorate. This project is expected to create 6,804 jobs.

The agreement signed with South Sinai’s governor Major General Khaled Fouda will result in an 18km legwork that will create 6,854 jobs. While these seem like development projects that will actually benefit the local population, environmentalists are concerned about some of the promises made by presidential candidates.

The Muslim Brotherhood espoused the most elaborate plan for the peninsula, according to Al-Akhbar news. This is what it entails:

It envisaged dividing Sinai into five economic zones, and focusing development efforts on specific sectors in each (agriculture, commerce, manufacturing, and livestock herding in the northern zone around the provincial capital at al-Arish; mining and small industry in the central zone; agriculture, commerce, and livestock in the west; tourism in the southeast; and tourism along with mining and petroleum extraction in the southwest). Railways would also be built linking Sinai to Suez and Ismailia under the plan, which Mursi estimated would cost Egyptian Pounds (LE) 20 billion (US$3,300,000,000) over a period of five years.

Meanwhile Nature Conservation Egypt (NCE), one of the most outspoken voices for nature in the country, expressed concerns that these plans will proceed without due process, resulting in potential environmental catastrophes. Of greatest concern in Lake Bardawil, an important wetland near the Mediterranean Sea.

On the NCE Facebook page, Mindy el Bin wrote the following in response recently unveiled development plans in Sinai:

NCE supports Sinai Development…but sound and sustainable development that promotes utilization at the same time protection of the natural resource base. There are questions about the development plans…potential impacts? Where is the water coming from? Other alternatives for development i.e. tourism? Of course what is being described is intensive development with major environmental impacts…no talk about potential prevention or mitigation measures…this is the same type of development we had in the past…where is the change and progress?

After Mubarak and his cronies were ousted, we had hoped that Egypt would enter into a new era of responsible development. It’s still too soon to know whether programs will proceed without environmental impact assessments, but we’re definitely on the alert.

:: Bikya Masr

Image credit: Sinai, Shutterstock

More From Egypt, the Muslim Brotherhood and Sinai:

Greenwashing the Brotherhood

Egypt Slashes Longstanding Gas Deal with Israel 

Post-Revolution Development Destroys Popular Red Sea Dive Spot

About Tafline Laylin

As a tour leader who led “eco-friendly” camping trips throughout North America, Tafline soon realized that she was instead leaving behind a trail of gas fumes, plastic bottles and Pringles. In fact, wherever she traveled – whether it was Viet Nam or South Africa or England – it became clear how inefficiently the mandate to re-think our consumer culture is reaching the general public. Born in Iran, raised in South Africa and the United States, she currently splits her time between Africa and the Middle East. Tafline can be reached at tafline (at) greenprophet (dot) com, @teakettle22,

15 thoughts on “Sinai’s Ecological Future Hangs in the Balance

  1. New item 店内全品ポイント10倍

    I わからないブログ の問題の問題を 。 書かれたテキストテキストの一部ポストオフ実行しているあな​​たの かのように表示されます画面。 他の誰かがことができますしてくださいコメント、これは彼らに起こっているなら、私に知らせてあまりに?私はこれが起こる持っていたので、 Webブラウザブラウザ これは、することができる 前私と問題問題です。 乾杯
    New item 店内全品ポイント10倍

  2. 100%新品 商品到着後レビュー記載でプレゼント

    回答|スパムフィードバック?ので、どのようにあなたがしなければ示唆助言それは、任意のプラグインや、あなたができるもの低減? 私は最近、それが私を駆動するのはそんなにを取得するので、任意の援助非常に高く評価されています。
    [url=]100%新品 商品到着後レビュー記載でプレゼント[/url]

  3. 100%品質保障 商品到着後レビュー記載でプレゼント

    ご挨拶ねえ私はそうですうれしい私はあなたのブログのページを発見、私は本当に のための何か他のもの、関わらずのため素晴らしいポストとオールラウンド楽しいブログ(私もテーマ/デザインを愛して)楽しま、私は通読する時間がありません読み取りますこれですべての分私はブックマーク持っていることを、また、コメントを追加あなたのRSSフィード、私は時間があるときに、私は チョ·}以上、{素晴らしいを維持ください。
    [url=]100%品質保障 商品到着後レビュー記載でプレゼント[/url]

  4. 国内関税込 商品到着後レビュー記載でプレゼント

    こんにちは、 あなたのウェブサイト ことができる 互換性の問題 を有します。 たびに私は あなたの見取り、あなたを見て ブログ Safariで、それが正常に見えるしかし、とき開口部インターネットエクスプローラIEで、|いくつかの重複の問題をそれはしているそれが持っています。 私は |アップ素早く頭をご提供します与えるに欲しかったです! そのほか、素晴らしい ブログ!
    [url=]国内関税込 商品到着後レビュー記載でプレゼント[/url]


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

1 × 3 =