BrightSource Solar Energy Project In Mojave Desert Shelved
Karin Kloosterman | | 17 Comments | Email this

We’d been reporting over the last year or so about the California-Jerusalem company BrightSource and its plan to create a number of solar energy power plants in California’s Mojave Desert region. Early in the year it signed an historic contract with PG&E, as the power giant works to conform to California law and produce 20% of its energy from renewable sources by 2010.
We’re not sure if they’re going to make it: some intense friction between environmentalists and the renewable energy developers has led to the Mojave solar project being dropped, reports the New York Times.
According to the Times, BrightSource Energy Inc. had been planning its 5,130-acre solar power farm in a remote part of the Mojave Desert. But it was going to be built on land previously intended for conservation. The company, based in Oakland, California and Jerusalem, Israel, said that it would look for another site.
Blocking the project was The Wildlands Conservancy, a California-based enviro group, as well as Senator Dianne Feinstein, a Democrat, who suggested the area become a national monument.
Donated by Wildlands to the Interior Department, the land was to be protected under assurances made by the Clinton administration. But by 2005 and the new Energy Policy Act, the Bush administration said the land could be used for solar energy projects.
“We salute BrightSource for their responsible behavior,” said David Myers, executive director of Wildlands to the New York Times. “A major conflict between the environment and renewable energy is over.”
If the plan went ahead, the BrightSource power plant would have been installed “at the heart of a signature valley” an area replete with bighorn sheep and other natural wildlife.
BrightSource did not comment.
BrightSource has high profile investors like Google and is advised by Robert F. Kennedy Jr.
This latest turn of events, is yet another example of how the goals and priorities of clean technology industrialists need better alignment with environmentalists. It may also be one of how politicians use any controversy to strengthen their political campaigns.
Similar issues are at stake right now in Scotland as environmentalists fight over wind farms being installed in peat bogs. Not far from where I was born and raised in Canada, wind farms on the Thousand Islands, Wolfe Island, have transformed the traquil, and awe-inspiring landscape. Renewable energy is important for us to pursue, but not to the detriment of the very thing we are trying to protect. Something for us to think about.
::NY Times
More on BrightSource on Green Prophet:
California’s PG&E Signs Historic Solar Energy Contract With BrightSource Energy, for Solar Power
BrightSource Solar Energy Teams up with Bectel to build large California solar energy facility
BP Solar and SolarEdge Partner to Develop Power Harvesting System

17 Responses to “BrightSource Solar Energy Project In Mojave Desert Shelved”
greenprophet • September 21st, 2009 • 10:06 am
Green it! : BrightSource Solar Energy Project In Mojave Desert Shelved http://bit.ly/pFbrA
Maurice Picow • September 21st, 2009 • 11:19 am
Interesting this should show up when the local Globes financial news gave the project such good write ups, including the recent article on how Brightsource had teamed up with Bectel to do this project.
But as Will Rogers used to say: “all I know is what I read in the papers”.
Solar Energy Canada • September 21st, 2009 • 10:31 am
BrightSource Solar Energy Project In Mojave Desert Shelved – Green Prophet (blog) http://bit.ly/j03yA
Jim Davis • September 21st, 2009 • 11:12 am
http://bit.ly/10NrOO BrightSource Solar Energy Project In Mojave Desert Shelved | Green … http://bit.ly/y6yxJ
FloridaIsrael • September 21st, 2009 • 11:42 am
BrightSource Solar Energy Project In Mojave Desert Shelved – We’d been reporting over the last year or so abo… http://ow.ly/15Q4Rs
Karin Kloosterman • September 21st, 2009 • 12:44 pm
Business papers don’t usually support the concerns of environmentalists, unless it’s good for business. Best to bury heads in the sand and let them go away. The problem is that environmentalists are now winning victories, showing that it might be wiser to work hand in hand with them from the beginning.
BrightSource, as I’ve read, has a number of projects cooking around the world. The Mojave Desert is one of them.
thegreengod • September 21st, 2009 • 12:53 pm
BrightSource Solar Energy Project In Mojave Desert Shelved | Green …: Similar issues are at stake right now in.. http://tinyurl.com/nkb2sb
Solar Mamas & Papas • September 21st, 2009 • 2:09 pm
BrightSource Solar Energy Project In Mojave Desert Shelved | Green … http://tinyurl.com/nkb2sb
Alternative Energy Solar Wind | The future of wind power • September 21st, 2009 • 6:59 pm
[...] BrightSource Solar Energy Project In Mojave Desert Shelved | Green … Tags: Alternative Energy Solar Wind 0 Top [...]
Green Business Double Book Review | CleanTechies Blog - CleanTechies.com • October 1st, 2009 • 3:02 pm
[...] Rose, CEO of a large US sustainable urban development consultancy, Arnold Goldman founder of Brightsource Energy and Yosef Abramowitz of the Arava Power Company all combine strong ethical vision with a rigorous [...]
BrightSource Solar Expands On Coyote Land In Nevada | Green Prophet • October 2nd, 2009 • 9:55 am
[...] recent news that environmentalists lobbied to have a solar energy project cancelled in California due to fears it would ruin protected land in the Mojave Desert, BrightSource, the company in [...]
Our Golden Goose is Dying • October 19th, 2009 • 7:32 am
[...] energy management deals seem to have legs. The whole biofuel bubble is long burst. One of the most noteworthy solar facilities in the Mojave Desert has run afoul of NIMBY – the green movement shooting itself in the foot by [...]
Ken Arizona Desert Landscaping • October 31st, 2009 • 2:05 am
Lets hope they can still find a suitable place for this solar plant.
It would be a terrible thing if we had to fire up some of the power plants sitting in Arizona and other places, Using Coal or Natural gas instead of solar, to keep California supplied with power.
maybe another nuke plant at the border??? nobody wants that
But yes i Know the law requires they produce green energy but they just pass fines on to us the consumer anyway, big deal
Personally i am installing solar at my rural farm, where i grow trees, It is now much more affordable
Arizona Desert Landscaping
Solar Energy Developers Find Themselves in Green Versus Green Debate Over Coyote Land | Green Prophet • February 11th, 2010 • 1:46 pm
[...] which recently staged a demonstration of its solar energy technology at a test plant facility in Israel’s Negev Dessert has already been frustrated in building solar energy plants in desert areas of California regions of [...]
US Department of Energy Guarantees $1.4 Billion in Loans For BrightSource and World’s Largest Solar Thermal Plant | Green Prophet • February 23rd, 2010 • 1:57 pm
[...] Controversy loomed over coyote land, but now BrightSource with a US Gov guarantee will create largest solar energy project in the world, in Ivanpah CA. [...]
BrightSource-Chevron Joint Solar Project To Extract Heavy Oil, Suffers Losses | Green Prophet • June 10th, 2011 • 3:22 am
[...] which in the past had its mega solar energy projects in California even shelved at one point due to environmental and other issues, seemed to be improving its energy image, [...]
israeli : oil : gas » Blog Archive » BrightSource-Chevron Joint Solar Project To Extract Heavy Oil, Suffers Losses • June 10th, 2011 • 6:26 am
[...] which in the past had its mega solar energy projects in California even shelved at one point due to environmental and other issues, seemed to be improving its energy image, [...]